A pizza can make the first decision easy because it gives the table something concrete to discuss. Look at the pizza menu and ask what kind of toppings everyone actually wants tonight.
For a familiar combination, the menu has Plain Cheese and several build-your-own options. For a named specialty, compare the listed ingredients: The Usual brings pepperoni, mushroom, ham, red onions, and olives; the Islander’s Delight is Canadian bacon and pineapple; the Margherita takes a different direction with basil, tomatoes, garlic, and Parmesan. This is a menu choice, not a personality test.
Still torn? A side or salad can round out one pie, or you can add a second pizza when the group is split. If someone has moved beyond pizza altogether, the pasta menu is close by. The right order is the one the table is glad to see arrive.