Four friends can make a menu feel much larger than it is. One wants pizza, another has been thinking about pasta, and someone else says they are “not very hungry” until the food arrives.
Give everyone a first choice. Then look for one dish that people genuinely want to share. A pair of contrasting pizzas from the pizza menu can work; so can a pizza beside a pasta dish. If the table wants something to begin with, browse sides and salads together rather than ordering a second main out of habit.
You do not need to optimize every bite. Order enough variety for the group, ask about anything that is unclear, and enjoy the fact that four people made it to the same table. Find the restaurant’s current hours before you make the plan.