Some nights are easier once someone says, “Let’s get pizza.” That settles the general direction without settling every preference. The pizza menu still leaves room for a plain cheese pie, a named specialty, or a custom combination.
If the group is split, keep the conversation short and useful: which toppings are welcome, which are out, and whether anyone would rather choose from pasta? Add a salad or side if it gives people something else they genuinely want.
Then stop planning and have dinner. Check the current hours before you leave, particularly if the evening is already getting late.